|
Chapter
3. Human VulneRability, Poverty and Environment
3.3 Access
to Health Care, Environmental Quality and Vulnerability
Human health
is affected by a broad spectrum of factors including social,
economic, sanitary-hygienic and environmental conditions, life style,
access to health care services and the quality of health care
systems. According to WHO data, up to 80% of morbidity is due to
exposure to different environmental factors of a physical, chemical
and biological character (see appendix for fuller
version).
The Caucasus
was traditionally characterised by moderate to serious environmental
and hygienic conditions in urban and industrial areas, linked to its
underdeveloped sanitation infrastructure, environmental pollution
from industries and traffic, and serious sanitary-hygienic and
environmental problems in rural areas connected to the intensive use
of pesticides and other chemicals and poor sanitation infrastructure
or the lack thereof (Ministry of Environment and Nature Resources
Protection, Russian Federation, 1994).
High figures
of infectious diseases were traditionally reported in some parts of
the region. High morbidity due to typhus, dysentery and viral
hepatitis was observed in the cities of the North Caucasus. In rural
areas, gastrointestinal diseases and poliomyelitis caused morbidity
figures of higher than average values. High morbidity due to typhus
was observed in cities of Armenia and Azerbaijan as well (Ministry of
Environment and Nature Resources Protection, Russian Federation,
1994). Apart from this, there has always been and continues to be a
high risk for epizootic outbreaks in the North Caucasus, since the
region has natural sources for contagious diseases such as plague,
tularaemia, brucellosis. Lack of animal vaccination and poor
sanitary-epidemiological conditions only aggravate the situation.
Since
1990, sanitary-hygienic conditions have been worsening in the region.
Outbreaks of infectious diseases, especially gastrointestinal ones,
have become routine. They have also occurred in areas where they
hardly ever occurred before, namely Georgia (State Committee of the
Azerbaijan Republic on Nature Protection, 1993; UN-ECE/MNP of
Armenia, 2000; WHO/MoH of Georgia, 2001; Ministry of Environment and
Nature Resources Protection, Russian Federation, 1996).
This may be
traced to sharply reduced abilities of state sanitary-hygienic
services to conduct regular inspections of food products and drinking
water due to lack of finances and technical equipment. Existing water
supply and sewage systems are inadequately maintained and frequently
cross-contamination of sewage and drinking water occurs. Water intake
facilities are not properly protected and do not meet sanitary and
hygienic requirements. In many locations, the lack of chlorine does
not allow for proper treatment of drinking water. Over-loaded
landfills that do not meet health and environmental requirements, and
illegal dumpsites cause the contamination of ground waters, which are
the major sources for drinking water in many of parts of the region.
The overall
situation is such that the population in general has become
vulnerable to infectious diseases. The need to treat foodstuffs and
drinking water with utmost caution has become a fact of daily life
– an absolutely new situation that has not been necessary for
decades. The poor and IDPs living in refugee camps are especially
vulnerable. Considering existing economic problems and general
mismanagement, the above problems will continue to fester in the
short to medium term.
Although it
is very difficult to establish links between environmental pollution
and morbidity rates, there is some scientific evidence linking high
ambient concentrations of different pollutants emitted from
stationary and mobile sources to increases in the morbidity rate for
specific diseases like respiratory and cardiovascular diseases,
specifically, hypertension and heart attacks, skin and endocrine
diseases, cancer, and lowered children’s IQ. All these have been
routinely documented in leading industrial centres of the region.
Recent
ambient air quality data for selected major cities of the Caucasus
indicate declining or stable trends for most pollutants, due to the
fall in industrial activities and hence, industry-related emissions.
However, this is offset to some extent by an increase in
traffic-related emissions. In the South Caucasus, there is noticeable
trend of concentration of population and economic activity in the few
largest urban centres. These have led to a dramatic increase in
vehicles that are old (10 years or older), poorly maintained and use
low quality fuel. Traffic is poorly organised, and congestion is
routine. Since traffic is a major source for ambient air pollution in
most Caucasus cities, particulates and lead are assumed to be the
most serious health concerns. There are a number of studies
supporting this thesis, for instance, the study of health effects of
short-term exposure to TSP for the city of Yerevan (MNP of Armenia,
2001), studies for the cities of Baku, Sumgayit and Ganja on PM10
concentration (State Committee on Ecology and Control of Natural
Resources Utilization, Azerbaijan, 1998), and studies on lead impact
on health for Tbilisi (NORCE & MoE of Georgia, 2000).
During the
Soviet era, the morbidity and mortality rates due to neoplasm and
birth defects were traditionally high among the rural population of
the Caucasus, mainly due to unsustainable use of pesticides. At
present, whereas the overall pesticide use has declined here, health
concerns related to pesticides still exist. Specifically, many
individual farmers are not aware of health and environmental
requirements for pesticide use, and pose a high threat to their own
and other people’s health and environment. Another problem is
related to obsolete pesticides and other agro-chemicals that are not
properly stored and cause the contamination of ground waters and
soil. This poses a high risk to human health through drinking water
and food contamination.
The
situation in the public health care system has also dramatically
changed. While during Soviet times it was never very advanced or
efficient, it did provide universal access and was free. The
post-Soviet transition crisis has resulted in a marked deterioration
of this system, although this process has been uneven. Russia has
managed to retain the previously existing model and is even expanding
the system. On the other hand, a crisis in the system is obvious, and
quality is falling. It has become especially more discriminatory
towards the less affluent population since under-the-table payments
are almost mandatory. In the South Caucasus, the poor are virtually
alienated from the health-care system, in Armenia and Georgia quite
perversely because of the WB sponsored reforms.1
Even for the more affluent families paying for medical treatment can
often mean sliding below the poverty line. People routinely postpone
visits to doctors or self-medicate, causing additional aggravating
factors in the case of contagious and infectious diseases.
More
importantly, health-care systems have lost their ability to practice
preventative medicine and usually treat people in advanced stages of
disease. Poor infrastructure facilities, and the lack of technical
and financial resources to conduct the most routine sanitary and
hygienic oversight services are too much for the people in the system
to cope with. Although qualified professionals in the system still
exist, they too lag behind in their knowledge of recent tools and
methods used in contemporary toxicology and epidemiology.
Environmental and other authorities responsible for data collection
also do not have enough resources to regularly monitor ambient
environment quality, detect high pollution episodes and take specific
measures for human health protection. Existing ambient standards are
out of date and need revision. Besides, more often than not
authorities simply do not react to easily observable trends and
situations with obvious health hazards, while the public in general
lacks information, understanding, organisation and effective means to
alter the situation.2
1
- Obviously, absence of these reforms would have resulted in the same
alienation, but in the popular perception, reforms caused this
misfortune. We also do not specifically comment on the quality of
health services. High quality is rare and usually accessible only for
a very restricted stratum of the population.
2
- For instance, malaria that was virtually non-existent in Georgia
for decades started to re-emerge recently. It is mainly imported from
Azerbaijan as well as from Asian countries with a high prevalence of
this disease. High incidences in the Kakheti region adjacent to
Azerbaijan are primarily caused by the cessation of regular chemical
processing of few local reservoirs that naturally harbour the malaria
vector. This fact is widely known but no mitigating measures are
undertaken, even though resumption of processing is rather cheap and
well within the abilities of impoverished Georgian health-care
budget.
<<PREVIOUS
NEXT>>
|